I am not the type of person to regret decisions I’ve made in the past. Sure, there are some decisions I’ve made that didn’t work out quite the way I wanted, or caused way more angst and suffering than they should have **cough cough graduate school**. But I’m able to view them as valuable learning experiences that set me up well for something in my future. For instance, while there were many things in grad school that were beyond soul-sucking (like, say, the time I sat in a meeting with two professors who both argued vociferously IN MY PRESENCE about how neither wanted to advise me….or the time my advisor was initially denied tenure….), I learned (pretty damn quickly) how to advocate for myself, how to design my own dissertation project, how to apply for and navigate funding, and how to find and cultivate mentors and sponsors in a festering snakepit. And, of course, meeting my partner in grad school definitely (or, almost definitely) made the experience worthwhile.
I do, however, have one true regret: “retiring” from competitive swimming in 8th grade.
Now, this regret is a bit tricky, because it was a product of the limited options I had at the time. I was fortunate that my elementary / junior high school had a competitive swim team. It started when I was in 5th grade, maybe? My memory is a bit fuzzy. But I loved, loved, loved to swim and loved the water, so I joined and then swam all the way through 8th grade. Our season was during the fall, and I absolutely LOVED every minute of it. Practice, meets, the whole thing. I was never the fastest swimmer, but I improved every year (and won Most Improved Swimmer in 7th grade).
But the high school I attended (a small, all-girls Catholic high school) did not, at the time, have a swim team. There was a club team in my community, and I remember talking with my parents about joining that team after my 8th grade season ended. I ultimately decided against it. From what I can piece together from my (shoddy) memory of that time, it was partly fear of the unknown (the club team was GOOD and I was not super confident in my own skill and talent) and partly worry over family finances. So I gave it up.
I went on to do other things in high school and beyond — chorus and theater, leadership and service, church youth group stuff. I played softball (poorly). I did become a lifeguard as one way to scratch my swimming itch (and as a way to spend my entire summer in and around the water), and swam laps occasionally in college and beyond. But I always wondered “what if?”. What if I’d decided differently, and swam club in high school? What might have opened up for me? Would I have come to see myself as an athlete then, rather than well into adulthood?
I’m thinking about this more lately because I started swimming Masters one year ago (!!). I’m in the pool 2-3 days a week with excellent swimmers who swam in high school and college (and one who still competes at the Masters level). I work in a smaller group with a separate coach once a week to improve my skills. And…I’m improving significantly. I complete the workouts (something I couldn’t do at first) and, when I’m not chit-chatting or sneaking in extra rest between sets, I’m mostly keeping up with the group. I can do flip turns consistently, something I never thought I’d say as an adult.
Last week at our small group practice, another participant complimented my swimming and said “surely you swam in high school?” No, I said, I had to “retire” in 8th grade because there was no high school team. Our small group coached looked at me and said, with absolute sincerity, “Wow. What a waste of talent!” Which, I’ll be honest, floored me. Talent? For real? But at the same time, that one little comment brought vindication and possibly a bit of closure. The regret came from somewhere deep, somewhere that understood how very important swimming was at that point in my life, and acknowledged the cost of walking away from something so deeply held. My coach’s comment validated those deep feelings for me. And in a sense, this is freeing me to move on. I can’t change that choice years ago. But by taking up swimming again as an adult, and taking it seriously and working hard to improve and get faster and stronger, I can, in a sense, honor 8th grade me and restart down that untaken path.